Official bootlegs coming!

22 Responses

  1. James Peet says:

    Is this for real? I can't find it on iTunes (UK) and there's nothing online about it.

    Why not unbooted stuff as well?

  2. Popper says:

    Fantastic news. At long last!! EMI have only let the bootleggers cash in for about 40 years!

    If this is to become a regular year-by-year series, maybe will get Carnival of Light one day?…

  3. Scott Erickson says:

    F**K Carnival Of Light!
    the only reason anyone has any interest in that is because McCartney casually mentioned something about it once.

    Boy will everyone feel stupid when it turns out to be a bigger piece of $47T that we've heard about.

  4. Unknown says:

    Well this was unexpected.

  5. Unknown says:

    You can get Carnival Of Light on YOUTUBE if you really need it. Who knows if this is real or not. It does fit the description we've heard about all these years.

    youtube.com/watch?v=W9iOkz_5X-I

  6. Sair says:

    Seems too good to be true. (Paul talked about Carnival Of Light on his recent BBC In Concert interview.)

  7. wardo says:

    This is all great, but… where the hell is the Christmas Album?

  8. sandandglue says:

    I've no doubt it'll be bootlegged itself by early January.

  9. lewiecaw says:

    Nothin you can sing that can't be sung…

  10. wogew says:

    It looks like Apple/Universal are not about to give us something new, all they want is to be the ones to capitalise on these tracks which already has been circulating on earlier bootlegs. But they will be upgrades compared to the boots. This may only be a 1-shot deal. Like Steve commented in his column at Examiner, much like the Dylan copyright extension sets, this "album is to counter the recent non-EMI releases in Europe that have included Beatles tracks."
    Meaning that, since EU copyright law is changing next year, we probably won't be seeing a 1964 version. This probably also explains why Apple didn't include any 1962 (or earlier) material, since that stuff has already gone public domain.

  11. Gaz Hat says:

    Looks like the left overs from On Air with a few extras chucked in. All good though, I was going to be buying the BBC 10 CD Russian / Jap boot after Xmas anyway…

  12. Popper says:

    Thanks for telling me why I am interested in Carnival of Light, Scott. You are so wise.

  13. Unknown says:

    The Law isn't changing next year, it's already changed. Anything not released in the 50 years since it was recorded automatically becomes Public Domain in the EU under the 'Use it or Lose it' part of the new Copyright directive that came into place on 1st November. If this is to counter act that then, yes, it is possible that you will see other releases on a yearly basis by multiple artists. The point is that if they issue these tracks in 2013 they are then protected for another 70 years, if they don't they will become public domain on 1st January 2014.

  14. Nicki says:

    well, these are clearly being released to beat the public domain issue.
    But if they sell well, maybe, just maybe there may be more to follow…

  15. James Peet says:

    There must still be tapes we've not heard, from 1963 and maybe earlier. It's a strange situation and I can see Apple/Universal/Beatles losing some goodwill over this if they charge great amounts for stuff that was never intended for release and (presumably) is of a lower standard than the Anthology material.

  16. db says:

    I'm up for hearing 13-mins of unreleased Beatle-music from 1967 any day of the week. Even if it turns out to be (subjectively) crap.

    The other track Macca likes to tease with is that unfinished Threetle track, which he's said he'd like to finish. I hope he doesn't. It turns out you can reheat an omelette, just about.

  17. omnipop1026 says:

    Hi there,

    Thus is welcome even its only to beat the boots, but only on iTunes?? I don't use mp3(ugh), wish they would be available @ CD quality…

    I doubt McCartney would re-heat an omelette, he does not eat eggs!!

  18. Unknown says:

    This would be so much better if they'd tried a bit harder. They could have put it out in nice packages.They could have a BBC boxset and an album of sessions.

  19. 1 Mojofilter says:

    By the way, the quote from McCartney, relating to his opinion concerning a Beatles reunion was "You can't re-heat a souffle".

  20. Graeme s says:

    I was able to download these tracks in Australia, but four of the BBC tracks contain inaccurate information in relation to recording and broadcast dates. Tracks 18, 20, 21 and 22 are listed as having been broadcast on the 26th January 1963, however the recording info for 22nd January, when the Saturday Club tracks for Jan 26 were recorded does not include these tracks. Listening and comparing suggests that Track 18 was probably broadcast on March 16, 1963, while Tracks 20 and 21 were broadcast on May 25, and track 22 on June 29 of that year.

  21. Nicola Battista says:

    and, speaking of unreleased stuff from 50 years ago…
    djshop.de/Download-the-beatles-she-loves-you-twist-shout-live-in-stockholm-1963/ex/s~details,u~10069514,p1~mp3/xe/details.html

  22. Nicola Battista says:

    Roger Stormo: actually while the law changed, it only applies to stuff that has been *published* within 50 years, and protection starts from the year of publication. So, tracks that were sitting in some archive but were published on Anthology 1 in 1995 are now protected for 70 years starting from 1995 (!). Instead, a studio take or live recording that was never released officially for 50 years can now be used.

Leave a Reply to UnknownCancel reply